| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Richard Morton | Ricky Morton | 43 |
| Martin Lunde | Marty Lunde | 20 |
| Ray Fernandez | Hercules Hernandez | 18 |
| Ray Fernandez | 'Sheik' Hercules Hernandez | 17 |
| Dale Veasey | Dale Veasey | 15 |
| Matt Osborne | Matt Borne | 12 |
| Bruce Woyan | 'Mad Dog' Buzz Sawyer | 12 |
| Ray Fernandez | AKA Mr. Wrestling III | 11 |
| Rick Rood | Rick Rood | 10 |
| Matt Osborne | Matt Borne (Archive footage) | 9 |
| Dick Slater | 'Mr. Unpredictable' Dick Slater | 7 |
| Dick Slater | Dick Slater | 5 |
| Barney Irwin | 'Wild' Bill Irwin | 3 |
| Martin Lunde | Arn Anderson | 3 |
| David Ferrier | Jimmy Backlund | 3 |
| Pezavan Whatley | The Shadow | 2 |
| Troy Graham | Troy Graham | 2 |
| David Ferrier | Jerry Backlund | 2 |
| James Williams | Jimmy Garvin | 1 |
| James Williams | 'Gorgeous' Jimmy Garvin | 1 |
| Billy Haynes | Billy Haynes | 1 |